Hi Everyone,
Thanks for the welcomes and thoughts.
Sower: I love talking about the Bible and how it applies to my beliefs and I see a great consistency there.
I hope I’m not giving the wrong impression. I am very happy with the truths that I have learned in my life and I will defend, and have defended, them vigorously when needed. I am here because I enjoy religious discussion and talking about the Bible. I also enjoy learning why others believe what they believe.
I am very aware of the Tanners and their work. I find they make liberal use of half truth to stretch a point and I have seen many examples of how their data is not to be relied on. Here is a link to an article that shows how selective they can be when they choose quotations:
http://www.fairlds.org/apol/misc/misc20.htmlI have a friend who has met them and they seem like nice enough people but their scholarship leaves much to be desired.
Symphony: My login name comes from a quote about being clean ‘every wit.’ The ‘whit’ part is a play on my last name.
The ‘Mountain Meadows Massacre’ which is the common name for the killing of the wagon train from Arkansas, has been a black eye in our history every since it happened. My mother told me about it when I was about 16 years old, about 24 years ago, and the known details of the incident have not changed significantly since. The only ‘spinning’ that has been going on is that people, like this New York Times reporter, keep resurrecting the details of the incident with supposed new information. I have read much on the subject and the proven details of what happened have not significantly changed in more than 100 years. People like to make a big deal of the fact that Mormons were involved, they seem to want to keep that in the public eye. Others try to tie the Church hierarchy into the unfortunate incident just as they have tried for over a century with no luck. I find it fascinating that this article makes it sound like it hasn’t ever come to light that there were Mormons involved until recently and the Church somehow has successfully covered it up. Well I heard about it 24 years ago and like I said, the details have not changed in over a century. Here is a very extensive treatise on the subject and almost all of the quotes are from well before the turn of the century:
http://www.angelfire.com/sk2/ldsdefense/mmm.htmlIf the article is trying to make it sound like it is a new thing that we now know more than just Indians were involved then his/her scholarship is very poor and he/she is looking for sensationalism as apposed to real journalism. By the way, if you search the above website for the name Laban Morrill, that is my great great Grandfather. He tried to ease the fear of the community leaders towards the Arkansans ( I grew up in Arkansas by the way.) He also testified at the second trial of John D. Lee, the man ultimately convicted of wrong doing in the incident.
BlackEyedPeas: I hope I can join some good Bible discussions when I have time. Thanks for the welcome.
JudgeNot: Thanks for the kind words towards Mormons. I must say I have met many kind Evangelical Christians of different denominations and we usualy agree to disagree though I have ongoing discussions with several. I seem to always have an email debate of some kind going with Evangelical friends on the internet. I look forward to learning more about you.
Thanks All,
Nathan